The Midnight Club (Season 1, 2022)
Creators: Mike Flanagan & Leah Fong
Cast: Iman Benson, Igby Rigney, Ruth Codd, Annarah Cymone, William Chris Sumpter, Adia, Aya Furukawa, Sauriyan Sapkota, Matt Biedel, Samantha Sloyan, Zach Gilford, Heather Langenkamp
The Midnight Club follows an octet of terminally-ill teenage patients at Brightcliffe Hospice as they gather at midnight to share scary stories. – IMDB
Based primarily on the 1994 novel of the same name by Christopher Pike as well as adapting some of his short stories of various other books, The Midnight Club is a horror mystery thriller directed by Mike Flanagan which takes place in a hospice and the eight terminally-ill young adults who form The Midnight Club, following a long line of patients who are part of this club that get together at midnight to share scary stories and have a pact that whoever dies first will find a way to reach out if they can. The admission of their latest member, Ilonka (Iman Benson) stirs up the group as she tries to find the truth behind a story about a past patient who disappeared from the hospice and came back completely healed.
While I haven’t read the source material, The Midnight Club has an appealing execution and series structure. There’s a sense of watching an anthology as each episode focuses around a story told by one of the young adults which seemingly reveals a part of their own story with a twist. At the same time, the main storyline also strings through their conflicts and realities that they need to face with family that struggles to accept their illness or simply their own personal issues. This structure does have similar anthology genre issues where some stories are stronger than others and the scary element varies from some that push the outwardly unnerving but others are more subtle psychological horror. While it might have a little of something for everyone, it might not hit everyone the same. The central storyline follows each of them but Ilonka is a central focus as she starts to encounter odd things in the establishment itself as well as discovering more about the area that the hospice resides as well, which gives character to the location as well (something that I’m personally a big fan of).
Running at ten episodes, The Midnight Club manages to its rhythm well. While the scares aren’t like its previous shows and its set as a limited series instead of a mini-series, the series sets up the foundation for its characters and creates a mysteriously sinister location with Brightcliffe Hospice as it explores both the supernatural, cultist and historical elements. The characters also have their own uniqueness whether its their terminal illness or their personality, which creates a good balance between the harmony and friction to better understand these characters.
Mike Flanagan’s creations usually bring back familiar faces from previous projects that fit into this one. In this case, a good portion of his previous project Midnight Mass is here while adding in some new faces from its main leads like Ilonka played by Iman Benson or Anya played by Ruth Codd in her debut role to veteran cast like Heather Langenkamp who takes on the role as the doctor who runs the hospice. The Midnight Club truly shines in its characters because its them who tells the different stories and also shines the light on their struggles with their respective terminal illnesses as they experience loss, friendship and acceptance as well as all the unknown creepy things happening around them. While Ilonka’s character feels the most fleshed out in the group and she even has her own little mission, investigation and even romance along the way, Ruth Codd in her debut role here as Anya truly does steal the show. Despite its young cast being the focal point, most of the characters are well-written and believably portrayed.
Overall, The Midnight Club isn’t exactly what Mike Flanagan has done before on Netflix but at the same time, it still sticks a lot to the atmospheric execution that he is very good at. While it might not be as strong as its previous Netflix offerings from Mike Flanagan (which is pretty high bar that he set for himself), The Midnight Club still offered a lot of fun moments and the concept itself is unique as it explores so much more than just death. With a slated limited run of two seasons, it feels like a silly thing to just cancel it with just one more season to do especially since the first season set up the foundation of the series and its character incredibly well and had quite a few mysteries left to explore. Pity that we won’t get to see what happens.